You and I - The Curtain Falls | Screamo Hall of Fame Class of 1999 Nominee

Release Information:

6/1/1999
Level Plane Records
New Brunswick, NJ (Tri-State)
Runtime: 22:12
Tracks: 8

Band Members:

Casey Boland (Guitar, Vocals)
Thomas Schlatter (Guitar, Vocals)
Justin Hock (Bass, Vocals)
Chris Boland (Drums)

At a Glance:

Screamo, Post-Hardcore, Metalcore, Noisy, Energetic, Melodic

Musical Analysis:

Compared to the precision metallic chugging of their last album, You and I incorporates messier production, more chaotic songwriting and less sharp guitar tones on their sophomore full-length. Despite the quiet-loud dynamics, You and I once again manage to instill their songs with boundless kinetic energy, aided by the powerful vocal performance that mixes screams and cleans. However, the lower volume shifts seem more solemn than before, perhaps giving this record the emotional edge. Taking cues from Indian Summer, much of the transitions between songs on this album sample an old Stevie Wonder song.

Historical Analysis:

By 1999, You and I had already established themselves as the Screamo Kings of the LI-NJ Hardcore scene, even far outpacing bands like Saetia. With the release of their swan song The Curtain Falls, they further cemented this notion. Their popularity began blossoming, playing shows as far as Chicago, IL, New Bedford, MA and Nottingham, UK! However, this legacy would soon be paved over and their immense contributions to the genre would be somewhat shoved to the wayside. Alas, this is why You and I again missed the Hall of Fame - but their two amazing LPs still deserve recognition.

Lyrical Analysis:

Utilizing multi-layered lyrics from multiple vocalists, You and I seems to take their name seriously. Their personal lyrics regarding ongoing trauma and the struggle for self-reclamation, the fear of confessing love and being vulnerable, trying to find meaning in a chaotic world - all of these are blended with political issues like the scripting of freedom in Capitalism and the corrosion of unity amidst rampant individualism. In the end, all they have left - individualism, love, family - collapses underneath them with little hope left.

You and I - Saturday’s Cab Ride Home | Screamo Hall of FAme Class of 1997 Nominee

Release Information:

10/18/1997
Spiritfall Records
New Brunswick, NJ
Runtime: 25:34
Tracks: 9

Band Members:

Justin Hock (Vocals)
Casey Boland (Guitar)
Thomas Schlatter (Guitar)
Jonathan Marinari (Bass)
Charles Butera (Drums)

Genres, Influences and Characteristics:

Screamo, Metalcore, Energetic, Melodic, Chaotic, Noisy

Musical Analysis:

Metalcore was a tremendous influence for this band on this record, featuring some genuinely powerful guitarwork filled with melody and technicality. Accentuating the twisted and chaotic screaming is a cheesy, somewhat off key clean vocal performance. Rarely does the band sit still, even when transitioning to lower-intensity levels, largely due to the aforementioned active guitar and the tremendous drumming clinic.

Historical Analysis:

You And I's debut LP marks an evolving genre that further injects brutality with melody and technicality, somewhat similarly to Saeita. Particularly, the guitar work on this record transcends earlier Screamo and previews the intensity and technicality that the genre would be known for. Perhaps this is too much of a Metalcore album to deserve its place in the Screamo Hall of Fame but nonetheless deserves to be recognized for its quality and forward-thinkingness.

Lyrical Analysis:

With a band name like You And I, it’s no wonder that the majority of their lyrics tend to veer into the personal emotional side of the spectrum. Particularly, interpersonal relationships are the dominant topic, reaching into subjects like longing, vulnerability and the search for connection, the cruel passage of time, and the weight of emotional baggage. Of course, being a 90s Screamo band, they still touch up on political topics such as critiquing colonialism, but Hock’s words tend to expose inner-turmoil.