You and I - The Curtain Falls | Screamo Hall of Fame Class of 1999 Nominee

Release Information:

6/1/1999
Level Plane Records
New Brunswick, NJ (Tri-State)
Runtime: 22:12
Tracks: 8

Band Members:

Casey Boland (Guitar, Vocals)
Thomas Schlatter (Guitar, Vocals)
Justin Hock (Bass, Vocals)
Chris Boland (Drums)

At a Glance:

Screamo, Post-Hardcore, Metalcore, Noisy, Energetic, Melodic

Musical Analysis:

Compared to the precision metallic chugging of their last album, You and I incorporates messier production, more chaotic songwriting and less sharp guitar tones on their sophomore full-length. Despite the quiet-loud dynamics, You and I once again manage to instill their songs with boundless kinetic energy, aided by the powerful vocal performance that mixes screams and cleans. However, the lower volume shifts seem more solemn than before, perhaps giving this record the emotional edge. Taking cues from Indian Summer, much of the transitions between songs on this album sample an old Stevie Wonder song.

Historical Analysis:

By 1999, You and I had already established themselves as the Screamo Kings of the LI-NJ Hardcore scene, even far outpacing bands like Saetia. With the release of their swan song The Curtain Falls, they further cemented this notion. Their popularity began blossoming, playing shows as far as Chicago, IL, New Bedford, MA and Nottingham, UK! However, this legacy would soon be paved over and their immense contributions to the genre would be somewhat shoved to the wayside. Alas, this is why You and I again missed the Hall of Fame - but their two amazing LPs still deserve recognition.

Lyrical Analysis:

Utilizing multi-layered lyrics from multiple vocalists, You and I seems to take their name seriously. Their personal lyrics regarding ongoing trauma and the struggle for self-reclamation, the fear of confessing love and being vulnerable, trying to find meaning in a chaotic world - all of these are blended with political issues like the scripting of freedom in Capitalism and the corrosion of unity amidst rampant individualism. In the end, all they have left - individualism, love, family - collapses underneath them with little hope left.

Yaphet Kotto - The Killer Was in the Government Blankets | Screamo Hall of Fame Class of 1999 Nominee

Release Information:

1999
Ebullition Records
Santa Cruz, CA (NorCal)
Runtime: 33:01
Tracks: 9

Band Members:

Casey Watson (Guitar, Vocals)
Mag Delana (Guitar, Vocals)
Pat Crowley (Bass)
Scott Batiste (Drums)

At a Glance:

Screamo, Post-Hardcore, Emocore, Melodic, Energetic, Technical

Musical Analysis:

This record definitely gives off “Bay Area Screamo” vibes, though perhaps a hair older than some of the other NorCal classics. It takes the dynamic and emotional nature of Screamo, combines it with the melody, clean vocals, and riffs of late 90s Post-Hardcore, brings in a few elements of Emocore, and unveiled it to the world with this, their debut LP. There are tons of memorable riffs and strong melodies from the guitarists, seemingly the primary focus of this project, and the screamed / clean vocal combination amps the emotionality up severalfold. Some more traditional “Punky” moments come in where you can hear the blatant Emocore influence, contrasting the otherwise quite technical performance in most tracks.

Historical Analysis:

Although not the first album (or band) you’d consider when discussing the legacy of Bay Area Screamo, this seedling of a concept would continue to get fleshed out by legends like Funeral Diner and City of Caterpillar. This enigmatic Hardcore cocktail would serve as the basis for a melodic and experimental approach to the genre that this region would eventually be known for. Despite this quality and its forward-thinkingness, this record comes just shy of a proper HoF induction.

Lyrical Analysis:

Just by giving the cover of this record a brief glance, you can tell this is inherently political. These harrowing lyrics explore the relations between imperialism and religion, noting the historial revisionism that enables it, paradoxically working within a system that grinds you down and the myth of meritocracy. With violence so woven into the fabric of American life, we are all complicit in the sins of our history. Even when discussing interpersonal relationships, Yaphet Kotto can’t help but compare this to a war with no winners, each side assuring mutual destruction.

Saetia - Eronel | Screamo Hall of Fame Class of 1999 Nominee

Release Information:

1999
Witching Hour Records
New York, NY (Tri-State)
Runtime: 10:56
Tracks: 3

Band Members:

Billy Werner (Vocals)
Jaime Behar (Guitar)
Colin Bartoldus (Guitar)
Steve Roche (Bass)
Greg Dundy (Drums)

At a Glance:

Screamo, Midwest Emo, Math Rock. Melodic, Complex, Dynamic

Musical Analysis:

This EP is riddled with uncommon time signatures, complex rhythms and melodies and passionate vocals, which says nothing of how maturely and expertly these elements are stitched together. Delicate guitars, subdued drums and gentle but active basslines define the more fragile and quiet moments on here, smoothly switching to distorted tones, boisterous drumming and wild bass with ease. The high-pitched shrieks from their earlier work return, but Billy Werner’s utilizes other impressive vocal techniques like shouting, crooning clean notes and spoken word, giving the music another cryptic layer.

Historical Analysis:

Low-key, this is their best recorded material. It’s a testament to the increasing technicality and artistry of their music, even if these particular songs tend to go by the wayside when discussing Saetia and their material.

Being the band’s final recorded material for over a quarter-century, it was naturally the closest resemblance to what would become of this band - Hot Cross and Off Minor. There are definite similarities between the bands’ respective 2002 debut EPs and this 1999 one.

Lyrical Analysis:

Saetia once again poetically lean into personal tragedy and existential themes on their lyrics, somehow always coming back to a seemingly universal truth that they shared with their peers: the power of language tends to fail us. In particular, Werner digs into the struggles with self-indentity under the weight of unfulfilled potential, the existential misery of living through borrowed meaning in life and feeling unworthy of love.

I Have Dreams - Three Days ‘Til Christmas | Screamo Hall of Fame Class of 1999 Nominee

Release Information:

1999
Independent
Tallahassee, FL (Southeast)
Runtime: 15:53
Tracks: 5

Band Members:

Allen Compton (Vocals)
Mike Peters (Vocals)
Mike Hanson (Guitar)
Ben Seals (Bass)
Clayton Rychlik (Drums)

At a Glance:

Screamo, Metalcore, Midwest Emo, Dynamic, Energetic, Melodic

Musical Analysis:

Taking the bones of Screamo with emotionally intense screamed vocals and dynamic song structures, I Have Dreams concocted a formula all their own with plenty of chugging Metalcore riffage and the melodic sensibilities of Midwest Emo. Many of the songs swing jarringly between driving, intense sections, brutal breakdowns and clean, slightly cheesy concentrations of vocal and guitar melody. The entire record is gently wrapped in immutable youthful energy and raw, confessional emotional outpouring.

Historical Analysis:

The core of this band came together a year earlier, releasing a demo under the name New Ethic. Tragically, one of their guitarists would die young, leading to the formation of I Have Dreams and their sole release in 1999. This record serves as a tribute to their fallen friend, carrying on his musical legacy and allowing the young band members to express their deepest and saddest sentiments, the true basis of many great Emo artists.

Although a beloved cult classic now, it really took the Zoomers to bring this out of obscurity. While one of the best and most heartfelt releases of the entire 90s in Screamo, this one will be remembered as a hidden gem, not a Hall of Fame tour-de-force.

Lyrical Analysis:

With the aforementioned passing of this band’s former friend, the entire project revolved around their shared grief. After all, each band member was quite young during their time as I Have Dreams and DIY Hardcore was their outlet. Much like grief, the EP struggles as an emotional tide between bitter pain and joyous reverie. Grieving communally has allowed for healing, but the loss of their friend destroyed the future they all had together. The lifelong friendship has permanently shaped them as individuals, but the pain of grief leads to forgetting his face. Ultimately, the gratitude they have for him as a special part of their lives transcends the grief over losing their loved one. Grief strengthens love and vice versa.

Despite utilizing some truly playful screaming and cheesy clean vocals, the emotional vulnerability and rawness of the lyrics lead to well-earned catharsis. These are possibly the most personal lyrics on a release that we’ve covered yet.

Constatine Sankathi - Discography | Holy Grails 1998

The Artifact:

1998
Council Records
Runtime: 59:51
Tracks: 20

Artifact DNA:

Screamo, Emocore, Melodic, Dynamic, Quirky

Artifact Archeologists:

Christopher Sprague
Ian Pirtola
Joe Mattson
Rich Miles

Artifact Contents:

Both tracks from a split with Bev.Clone
Two tracks from various comps
All tracks from their Demo (unknown release date)
All tracks from their 1994 EP Who Killed the Killed Kid?
All tracks from their 1995 EP Baby Unicorn Tripped Over a Rock and Hurt Its Throat and Then Vomited
An original track

Artifact Echoes:

Constatine Sankathi’s discography is surprisingly fully realized and even across its near-hour length. Taking the last decade of Emocore as a blueprint while adding aggression and one of the weirdest trumpets you've ever heard, Constatine Sankathi's output is emotionally potent and dynamic, chaotic at times and serene at others. Half the time, that serenity is broken up by a bonkers and frankly reckless trumpet that may turn some listeners off but adds to the discordant atmosphere.

Artifact Legacy:

The band represents Kalamazoo (and all of Michigan, by extension) with profound and forward-thinking early Screamo. They took what Emo scene compatriots Ordination of Aaron were doing and injected it with heaviness and aggression. By mid-90s Screamo standards, they were recording some truly crazy and forward-thinking stuff, but their legacy seems trapped in ice in the Great Lakes.

Artifact Value:

Approximately 1,500 copies of this CD were made available over a couple for different runs. Overall, while not as highly sought after as other Grails, this can still run you at least $20, if not closer to $30+. Not bad for some local Michigan boys!

Stack / Jasemine / Disclose | Holy Grails 1998

The Artifact:

1998
Independent
Runtime: 46:38
Tracks: 22

Artifact DNA:

Powerviolence, Screamo, D-Beat, Hardcore Punk, Emocore, Frantic, Melodic, Heavy

Artifact Archeologists:

Stack

Bernd Bohrmann (Vocals)
Chris King (Guitar)
Marcel Hammenman (Guitar)
Corey Von Villiez (Bass)
Ralf Lombardo (Drums)

Jasemine

Christophe Mora (Guitar, Vocals)
Thomas Guillanton (Bass)
Jérome Bessout (Drums, Vocals)

Disclose

Tsukasa (Vocals)
Kowakami (Guitar)
Yousei (Bass)
Naoto (Drums)

Artifact Contents:

All tracks from Stack’s 1994 Demo
All tracks from Jasemine’s 1994 Demo
All tracks from Disclose’s 1992 Crime Demo
All tracks from Disclose’s 1993 Conquest Demo

Artifact Echoes:

Uniquely a three-band split Comp, the first artist features strong, straightforward Hardcore, featuring some interesting buildups. Although far from the genre itself, they seem to borrow a bit from early German Screamo artists, a scene that the band would dip their feet into a few times.

The next artist represented is Jasemine, whose 1994 Screamo demo is quite revolutionary. This is one of the earliest true Screamo releases in France, borrowing the melodic Emocore aesthetic and combining it with some harsh Hardcore Punk in a way that resembles what Screamo would become far better than some of the earlier bands that attempted such a combination. Notably, the screaming is raw, emotional and intense, imparting profound feelings unto the listener. This forward-thinking piece of Screamo could easily pass for something in the late 90s with poor production.

Disclose’s early work is seminal D-Beat music with pounding drums, hyper, Hardcore chord progressions and deep, shouted vocals. If you know anything about D-Beat, and specifically Japanese D-Beat, this should do it for you. If you are unaware, think of Crust Punk (Metal-influenced Punk) but simpler.

Artifact Legacy:

Is this thing even a real release? There isn’t a lot of info on how this came together, with most sources saying this was never an official release from any of the bands. Regardless, this cassette represents early 90s international Hardcore in its various forms. Germany, France and Japan, three longstanding Hardcore sanctuaries, are on display in this excellent collaborative compilation.

Artifact Value:

As this is likely bootleg, I literally can’t find this on sale. I’d imagine if you can find a copy, it’d be a pretty nice rarity to have. This is quintessential international Hardcore from the early 90s.

Envy - From Here to Eternity | Screamo Hall of Fame Class of 1998 Nominee

Release Information:

8/11/1998
HG Fact Records
Tokyo, Japan
Runtime: 33:54
Tracks: 11

Band Members:

Tetsuya Fukagawa (Vocals)
Masahiro Tobita (Guitar)
Nobukata Kawai (Guitar)
Manabu Nakagawa (Bass)
Dairoku Seki (Drums)

Genres, Influences and Characteristics:

Screamo, Melodic, Energetic, Dynamic, Raw

Musical Analysis:

On this LP, Envy crafted gorgeous, pure, cathartic Screamo, just as you would expect. In particular, their dense, heavy guitars would overwhelm if not threaded with clean, standalone guitar arpeggios, tasteful melodic lead lines, dynamic song structures and endless kineticism. This all combines with Fukagawa's intense vocal performance to produce astonishing results.

Historical Analysis:

Simply put, this album is integral to the formation of Japanese Screamo. Although Envy's primary influence on the genre seems to be the integration of Post-Rock, that innovation in and of itself was spurred from Envy's injection of melody into heavy Screamo.

Prior to this album, Envy had undergone numerous lineup and stylistic changes since their 1992 formation, but they would have about two decades with this lineup, wherein all of their legendary material would be released. Special to Japan, this record serves as a harbinger of what's to come more than a standalone entry into the Hall.

Lyrical Analysis:

*Note that because this is an old release in the grand scheme of Emo and Screamo history, I cannot locate lyrics for any of these songs. If more lyrics can be dug out, I will reevaluate the lyrical analysis. Please note any lyrical analysis on my end will lack cultural nuance and accuracy in the translation.*

Saetia - Saetia | Screamo Hall of Fame Class of 1998 Inductee

Release Information:

1998
Mountain Records
New York, NY
Runtime: 28:45
Tracks: 9

Band Members:

Billy Werner - Vocals
Adam Marino - Guitar
Jaime Behar - Guitar
Colin Bartoldus - Bass
Gregory Drudy - Drums

Genres, Influences and Characteristics:

Screamo, Midwest Emo, Math Rock, Complex, Dynamic, Melodic, Raw, Aggressive

Musical Analysis:

Coming a year off the heels of their revered demo, Saetia’s 1998 s/t LP is a revelation of Screamo music, taking their formula and supercharging it. The dynamic song forms return with more intensity than ever, balancing perfectly with the softer melodic parts of the album. Introduced in this release are strong Math Rock influences, giving their songs more unpredictability, varying odd time signatures, rhythmic complexity and an overall higher level of technicality than ever. This intricacy adds even more dynamism to their songs, emphasizing the poignant melodies and depravity more than before.

Historical Analysis:

The opening salvo of their discography was a monumental step forward for Screamo, but this album is perhaps one of the most influential works in the genre's history. This bold statement basically defined what Screamo would sound like at its peak and turned the somewhat silly subgenre into one capable of high art. The final shackles of Hardcore Punk and Post-Hardcore that held the genre together early on have evaporated and Screamo genre conventions were truly their own.

This album is the blueprint for which countless Screamo bands took inspiration, even if we’d have to work through a few more years of Emoviolence prominence before Saetia’s influence would be the defining sound. Besides this legendary status, the music itself is exceptional and would likely qualify for the Screamo Hall of Fame even without its legacy.

Lyrical Analysis:

Saetia fully embraces nihilism on this s/t. From just the title of the first song, the band reflects on how language is a lie we use to deceive ourselves, the destructive power of words and the failure of human systems. It sure seems like personal and collective misery is at the forefront of their lyrical themes, but their nihilistic worldview cuts both ways: sure, words are a lie and they tend to destroy relationships, but they also compose art - and art is a divine struggle. Yes, relationships can fail and you can subsequently fall, but there is power in rising above. Of course, the body exists as a tool of self-hatred and a reminder of our temporary mortal condition, but there is freedom in the emptiness. These are among the most poetic and artistic lyrics in the entire genre to this point.

Peu être / Carther Matha / Rachel | Connective Tissue 1997

Peu être

(Niort, Nouvelle-Aquitaine, France)

Gérome Desmaison
Laurent Daudin
Mike Ramounet

Carter Martha

(France)

Antoine De Lassée
Eric Surmont
Gérome Desmaison
Sébastien Janouin

Rachel

(France)

Nicolas Marilleau (Vocals)
Antoine De Lassée (Guitar, Vocals)
Laurent Daudin (Guitar)
Eric Surmont (Bass)
Sébastien Fouet (Drums)

Basic Info:

Release Date: 1997
Label: Le brun le roux corporation
Runtime: 1:11:18
-Peu être: 22:16
-Carther Matha: 26:46
-Rachel: 22:16
Tracks: 26
-Peu être: 8
-Carther Matha: 11
-Rachel: 7

Genres, Influences and Characteristics:

Screamo, Melodic, Dynamic

Points on a Timeline:

With eight members between the three bands and more than their share of cross-pollination, these staples of the 90s French Screamo scene came together at very similar points in their lifespans. All three bands started off in the mid-90s with demos, with perhaps Peu être forming and releasing their material first in ‘94. This split would be the last major work from any of these bands, however; Peu être didn’t release any material after this until their brief reformation in 2011. For Carther Matha, this would be the last the world would hear from them. Rachel would continue as a band the longest, releasing their final EP in 2001.

Shapes in the Sound:

Right off the bat, I need to address this: yes, these bands do sound fairly similar, but as I’ve previously mentioned, there are only eight interconnected members among these bands, all likely from the same region of Western France, so this tracks. As far as similarities go, they all have the “French Screamo” sound. What is that? It’s the marriage of emotional intensity, dynamic aggression and gorgeous melodies, melding them together in a winning formula that would be iterated upon for years to come.

Peu être utilizes dense guitar textures to craft atmosphere, Carther Matha have very-defined clean sections and have the closest ties to Hardcore, and Rachel, with perhaps the gnarliest vocalist of the bunch, packs their tracks with more length, bigger builds and emotional gravitas.

Threads in the Tapestry:

Simply put, this is a statement release for French Screamo and Western France. Several prominent musicians collaborated on this ambitious release, with each band contributing an LP's worth of music to the cause. This release would fade into obscurity as the genre grew in prominence, particularly in France, but the 1+ hours of pure 90s French Screamo preserves in amber an active and important scene in the development of this intense genre.