I Have Dreams - Three Days ‘Til Christmas | Screamo Hall of Fame Class of 1999 Nominee

Release Information:

1999
Independent
Tallahassee, FL (Southeast)
Runtime: 15:53
Tracks: 5

Band Members:

Allen Compton (Vocals)
Mike Peters (Vocals)
Mike Hanson (Guitar)
Ben Seals (Bass)
Clayton Rychlik (Drums)

At a Glance:

Screamo, Metalcore, Midwest Emo, Dynamic, Energetic, Melodic

Musical Analysis:

Taking the bones of Screamo with emotionally intense screamed vocals and dynamic song structures, I Have Dreams concocted a formula all their own with plenty of chugging Metalcore riffage and the melodic sensibilities of Midwest Emo. Many of the songs swing jarringly between driving, intense sections, brutal breakdowns and clean, slightly cheesy concentrations of vocal and guitar melody. The entire record is gently wrapped in immutable youthful energy and raw, confessional emotional outpouring.

Historical Analysis:

The core of this band came together a year earlier, releasing a demo under the name New Ethic. Tragically, one of their guitarists would die young, leading to the formation of I Have Dreams and their sole release in 1999. This record serves as a tribute to their fallen friend, carrying on his musical legacy and allowing the young band members to express their deepest and saddest sentiments, the true basis of many great Emo artists.

Although a beloved cult classic now, it really took the Zoomers to bring this out of obscurity. While one of the best and most heartfelt releases of the entire 90s in Screamo, this one will be remembered as a hidden gem, not a Hall of Fame tour-de-force.

Lyrical Analysis:

With the aforementioned passing of this band’s former friend, the entire project revolved around their shared grief. After all, each band member was quite young during their time as I Have Dreams and DIY Hardcore was their outlet. Much like grief, the EP struggles as an emotional tide between bitter pain and joyous reverie. Grieving communally has allowed for healing, but the loss of their friend destroyed the future they all had together. The lifelong friendship has permanently shaped them as individuals, but the pain of grief leads to forgetting his face. Ultimately, the gratitude they have for him as a special part of their lives transcends the grief over losing their loved one. Grief strengthens love and vice versa.

Despite utilizing some truly playful screaming and cheesy clean vocals, the emotional vulnerability and rawness of the lyrics lead to well-earned catharsis. These are possibly the most personal lyrics on a release that we’ve covered yet.

Stack / Jasemine / Disclose | Holy Grails 1998

The Artifact:

1998
Independent
Runtime: 46:38
Tracks: 22

Artifact DNA:

Powerviolence, Screamo, D-Beat, Hardcore Punk, Emocore, Frantic, Melodic, Heavy

Artifact Archeologists:

Stack

Bernd Bohrmann (Vocals)
Chris King (Guitar)
Marcel Hammenman (Guitar)
Corey Von Villiez (Bass)
Ralf Lombardo (Drums)

Jasemine

Christophe Mora (Guitar, Vocals)
Thomas Guillanton (Bass)
Jérome Bessout (Drums, Vocals)

Disclose

Tsukasa (Vocals)
Kowakami (Guitar)
Yousei (Bass)
Naoto (Drums)

Artifact Contents:

All tracks from Stack’s 1994 Demo
All tracks from Jasemine’s 1994 Demo
All tracks from Disclose’s 1992 Crime Demo
All tracks from Disclose’s 1993 Conquest Demo

Artifact Echoes:

Uniquely a three-band split Comp, the first artist features strong, straightforward Hardcore, featuring some interesting buildups. Although far from the genre itself, they seem to borrow a bit from early German Screamo artists, a scene that the band would dip their feet into a few times.

The next artist represented is Jasemine, whose 1994 Screamo demo is quite revolutionary. This is one of the earliest true Screamo releases in France, borrowing the melodic Emocore aesthetic and combining it with some harsh Hardcore Punk in a way that resembles what Screamo would become far better than some of the earlier bands that attempted such a combination. Notably, the screaming is raw, emotional and intense, imparting profound feelings unto the listener. This forward-thinking piece of Screamo could easily pass for something in the late 90s with poor production.

Disclose’s early work is seminal D-Beat music with pounding drums, hyper, Hardcore chord progressions and deep, shouted vocals. If you know anything about D-Beat, and specifically Japanese D-Beat, this should do it for you. If you are unaware, think of Crust Punk (Metal-influenced Punk) but simpler.

Artifact Legacy:

Is this thing even a real release? There isn’t a lot of info on how this came together, with most sources saying this was never an official release from any of the bands. Regardless, this cassette represents early 90s international Hardcore in its various forms. Germany, France and Japan, three longstanding Hardcore sanctuaries, are on display in this excellent collaborative compilation.

Artifact Value:

As this is likely bootleg, I literally can’t find this on sale. I’d imagine if you can find a copy, it’d be a pretty nice rarity to have. This is quintessential international Hardcore from the early 90s.

Encyclopedia of American Traitors / Kwisatz Haderach - The Case of Joe Hill | Connective Tissue 1998

Encyclopedia of American Traitors

(Millersville, PA)

Andrew Martin
Keith Miller
Ryan Suffort
Steve " Yuletide" Sakasitz
Zachary Martin

Kwisatz Haderach

(Arlington, VA)

Geoffrey Todd Culbertson
Lucia Forte
Sam Gutterman
Todd Hoffman
Todd Neece
Yannis Stephanopoulos

Basic Info:

Release Date: 1998
Label: N/A
Runtime: 11:03
-Encyclopedia of American Traitors: 4:55
-Kwisatz Haderach: 6:08
Tracks: 4
-Encyclopedia of American Traitors: 2
-Kwisatz Haderach: 2

At a Glance:

Emoviolence, Frenetic, Atmospheric, Dynamic

Points on the Timeline:

Both of these small-time Emoviolence bands existed solely in the late 90s. EOAT was two splits and one EP deep into their career in 1998, with one more EP and a discography comp in their future. Kwisatz Haderach would only release an EP this year outside of this Split before calling it quits.

Shapes in the Sound:

Both of these bands execute dynamic Emoviolence with long, atmospheric buildups with some gnarly screams. EOAT tends to have more of a dichotomy between melody and dissonance, sounding somewhat like Saetia performing Emoviolence at times, while Kwisatz is a bit more “Hardcore,” for lack of a better term. Regardless, both of these artists took great care to ensure the hectic sections were balanced out.

Threads in the Tapestry:

This quick East Coast connection wasn’t well known, but both bands would flesh out Emoviolence in their respective regions. Though quite small time, members would go on to flourish in other Hardcore bands like Yaphet Kotto, Tiny Hawks and Virgina Black Lung.

Saetia - Saetia | Screamo Hall of Fame Class of 1997 Inductee

Release Information:

1997
Independent Release
New York City, NY (Tri-State)
Runtime: 14:42
Tracks: 4

Band Members:

Billy Werner (Vocals)
Adam Marino (Guitar)
Jaime Behar (Guitar)
Alex Madera (Bass)
Greg Drudy (Drums)

Genres, Influences and Characteristics:

Screamo, Midwest Emo, Post-Rock, Dynamic, Raw, Mysterious, Complex

Musical Analysis:

You come to understand the power of Saetia’s music within seconds of the intro track’s simple but harrowing intro, oscillating between complete silence and brash, distorted guitar. Entering next is Billy Werner’s iconic high-pitched screeches juxtaposed with frustrated, rapid-fire spoken word verses. As the songs progress, a profound sense of dynamic songwriting can be heard through the serene quiets and the frantic louds on this record. Saetia was definitely inspired by the style of Midwest Emo with intensity changes and twinkly guitar parts, more than the form.

This record isn’t just an establishment of Screamo tropes, though. It is a vibrant, seemingly-alive work of art that reflects the anguish of the band members. Despite each track going through its own arc, the entire EP seemingly builds up to an explosive crescendo in their final track. This is aided by the subtle Post-Rock influence that, while not as pronounced as in bands like Portraits of Past, gives this band the freedom to air out their emotions through extended instrumental passages.

Historical Analysis:

Whenever analyzing the discography of a Screamo band, never, and I mean NEVER, underestimate the power of a demo tape. Although this band would go on to have a legendary (if not short) career, this demo started it all. Featuring the two tracks from a single that would release that same year, this s/t Demo features some of the most beloved songs in the entire catalogue of the band. Countless artists would be inspired by these tracks alone, though Saetia would have quite the prolific career from here despite their brief run.

Lyrical Analysis:

Saetia’s prose-like approach to lyricism allows the band to tell extremely personal emotional tales through stream-of-consciousness verses, powerful repeated phrases and grandiose metaphors about regret and heartbreak. The band isn’t thematically novel, exploring the ideas of unrequited love, grief and nostalgia. Billy’s frenzied vocal delivery imparts desperation and immediacy upon the listener, only to slow things down with clean spoken words that are clearly and painfully understood. Many Screamo bands would blend in political and social ills with personal misery, but Saetia looked entirely inward for motivational torment for these lyrics.

Breakwater - Demo | The Shape of Screamo to Come

Release Information:

1995
Independent
Victoria, BC, Canada
Runtime: 25:12
Tracks: 5

Band Members:

Jode Shortreed
Steve Simard
Dave Truscott
Dave Wenger

Genres, Influences and Characteristics:

Screamo, Post-Hardcore, Post-Rock, Midwest Emo, Lofi, Dynamic, Atmospheric, Cold

Musical Analysis:

Despite its less-than-ideal recording conditions, Breakwater’s Demo showcases a potent Punk cocktail of Screamo, Post-Hardcore, Post-Rock and Midwest Emo, many of these genres in their infancy. Extended instrumental passages of twinkly arpeggios comprise the bulk of the softer, quieter sections, acting as a depressive glue for the fiercer, louder moments. The interplay between these intensities is as suffocating and disorienting as it is beautiful, and with each song averaging just over five minutes, there’s lots of room for each track to breathe and reach its destination naturally.

Historical Analysis:

Straddling the line between burgeoning genres like Screamo and Midwest Emo, their eclectic mix is fairly common now, but in 1995, this was revolutionary. If anything, this release showcases the shared history of all Emo subgenres and their connection to Post-Hardcore and Hardcore Punk. In that sense, this obscure Canadian collection of songs is a revolutionary album, despite being lesser-known than their Five / Seven single (which are both on this demo). Introducing lengthy Post-Rock elements was also quite novel, though it would become genre-defining in just a few short years.

Lyrical Analysis:

Breakwater's straightforward and frank lyrics may not seem all that special at first glance, but spouting such introspective rhetoric wasn't hugely common, at least without some social or political underpinnings. That isn’t to say the songs are apolitical, rather they focus on the personal side of generational hardships, helplessness, corrosive love and even the sting of truth. Their directness and sincerity make the lyrics digestible for almost anyone who listens.

Malva - Malva | The Shape of Screamo to Come

Release Information:

1994
Independent
Leverkusen, Nordrhein-Westfalen, Germany
Runtime: 13:30
Tracks: 5

Band Members:

Martino Palazzo (vocals)
Christian Schneider (guitar)
Florian Reiss (guitar)
Alexander Jahn (bass)
Alexander Bokelmann (drums)

Genres, Influences and Characteristics:

Screamo, Emocore, Passionate, Raw, Melodic, Lofi

Musical Analysis:

The first thing you'll likely notice is the melody and quiet intensity of the band; the second thing is invariably the passionate and coarse vocal delivery from Martino, who at times is on the verge of emotional collapse while putting the maximum strain his vocal cords will allow. Other times, the vocal performance is clean and resigned, as if completely defeated. The muddy production values actually work in favor of the arrangements, allowing the treble to be prominent and emphasize the high end that the band is comfortable playing in.

Historical Analysis:

Outside of a burgeoning French Screamo scene, Germany was the next beneficiary of this movement and one of the earliest examples of Screamo from the region is Malva’s self-titled demo. Eschewing the Hardcore Punk influence of older Screamo, such as Ivich, I wouldn’t describe the sound as “lighter,” but rather its focus is different. Malva utilizes disharmony, distorted melodic lead lines and a higher-register screaming style compared to traditional Hardcore, but it’s as impactful. In particular, the vocal performance is among the most raw in the genre’s infancy.

Lyrical Analysis:

*Note that because this is an old, DIY and relatively minor release in the grand scheme of Emo and Punk history, I cannot locate lyrics for any of these songs. If more lyrics can be dug out, I will reevaluate the lyrical analysis.*