Barely Civil - I'd Say I'm Not Fine

B Tier

I’d Say I’m Not Fine is another solid outing from longtime Wisconsin Emos Barely Civil and is modern Midwest Emo done right - hooking vocals, dynamic and diverse arrangements played with energy and sincerity. Despite the catchiness of the vocals and the vigor with which the band plays, nothing on this album quite stands out amongst their discography or the greater Emo tapestry of 2024. Still, your year isn’t complete until you hear this album at least once.